You are not logged in.

Reply

Dear visitor, welcome to SPRINKLER TALK FORUM - You Got Questions, We've Got Answers. If this is your first visit here, please read the Help. It explains how this page works. You must be registered before you can use all the page's features. Please use the registration form, to register here or read more information about the registration process. If you are already registered, please login here.

Attention: The last reply to this post was 3643 days ago. The thread may already be out of date. Please consider creating a new thread.

Message information
Message
Settings
Automatically converts internet addresses into links by adding [url] and [/url] around them.
Smiley code in your message such as :) is automatically displayed as image.
You can use BBCode to format your message, if this option is enabled.
Security measure

Please enter the letters that are shown in the picture below (without spaces, and upper or lower case can be used).

The last 10 posts

Friday, April 30th 2004, 3:17am

by houston

Alright everyone, we can get back to helping each other out as this forum intended. I just wish someone would ask an easy question that I know the answer to!

I maid a speling misteak? If I did it must have bean intenshunle to maik it luk like I kould maik a misteak 2!

Thursday, April 29th 2004, 9:21am

by aquamatic

FixItDaddy- My apologizes also to you for coming across as talking down to you- Not my intentions!


Thursday, April 29th 2004, 8:26am

by FixItDaddy

I apoligize for my aggresive remarks. Although I feel I didn't cast the first stone, its no excuse for my being drug into a p**sing contest. I guess I felt as though I was being talked down to, and I was taught to always stand up for myself.
houston, thank you, I caught the misspelling of "above" (about), and some missing apostrophe's in my first four posts here. As for those inside the quotes, they are verbatim from aquamatic. As for "through", Webster's shows "thru" as an informal, simplified spelling of "through". I guess I have rambled (mechanical engineering spelling for rampled) on enough on all of this. Again my apoligies.

Wednesday, April 28th 2004, 6:49pm

by HooKooDooKu

FixItDaddy,

Thanks for the pats on the back, but aquamatic is also correct in saying that you can still wind up with a flooded basement. While freezing most likely will not be an issue if you have a PVB installed indoors, as aquamatic stated, it is a mechanical device subject to failure.

I'll still stand by my claim that from a safety stand point, a PVB is safe in a basement (given that it will still be above the sprinkler heads, it will do it's job and prevent your house water from getting contaminated. It's just that in a failure condition, you get a very wet basement.


Wednesday, April 28th 2004, 2:45pm

by houston

FixItDaddy,

You should not have cast stones. You need to check your first three posts here and check your spelling.

I was a Manufacturing Engineer for 28 years and am now a Texas Licensed Irrigator, but I can still spell something wrong. What's the big deal about someone's education level. As far as I know, Aquamatic has a PhD in Nuclear Physics and just elects not to reveal it to us.

Also, I believe you and Aquamatic should have stated where you live before getting into a p**ssing contest. Here in Texas, besides State regulations, each municipality and even each subdivision can have it's own regulations that are tougher than the state and many of them do. Which is why I would not get into an argument with anyone around the Houston area that has worked in a different municipality or subdivision than I have personally done work in or have called and gotten the codes for.

As for Aquamatic, he has helped me tremendously on other forums and thru (manufacturing engineering spelling for through) private mail correspondence.

Sorry to have rampled on but my feathers got ruffled by a comment!

Wednesday, April 28th 2004, 11:46am

by FixItDaddy

Aquamatic, Maybe if the PVB was properly drained (or mounted inside) it wouldn't have froze and "bursted".
As for the reduced pressure zone (yes I know what it is), it should be used if any sprinkler outlet is higher than the backflow preventer. It's usually a last resort to a PVB or AVB since it requires an annual inspection and a rebuild every 5 years.
As for education, I have a B.S. in Mechanical Engineering (your spelling and grammar speaks for itself).
Thank you for your comments on the subject and no further information will be required.

Wednesday, April 28th 2004, 10:10am

by aquamatic

FixItDaddy- I am speaking for codes related to our area- If you would have read my entire quote on codes( most counties) 4 out of the 25 season startup we did last week had failed PVB's 1 of them was working fine when we started them up just to have the customer call us back two days later- It-s a mechanical device and failures can happen. The inside freeze protect bursted into pieces and the entire pressure flow was flowing off the top ( nothing to even do with the backpressure). The homeowner noticed by constantly hearing his water flow running - then noticed the pool of water outside by his PVB

Now lets imagine the same scenerio happens on a PVB that is stored indoors while the homeowner is away- Codes or no codes--- I think it makes more sense to mount it outdoors

If you want to install an indoor system go with an RPZ (If you know what they are) which the overflow is plumbed directly to a drain system.

As for educating myself- Maybe you should be a little careful on your words-
My opinion is not only backed with some education of national plumbing codes and knowledge of cross-connection prevention but experience and practical sense of what goes on and what could happen if a contarctor installs a device that could cause a homeowners basement to flood-

I noticed a few of your posts contradicts why certain things are done and why not your way because it makes sense to you- It actually sets apart a professional from an unprofessional- and its obvious where you fall.

We are setup in this forum to help each other out- not to insult our intelligence I have learned quite a bit myself from many others- My apologies to all others for such a defensive reply-

Wednesday, April 28th 2004, 7:24am

by FixItDaddy

Thanks for clarifying things HooKooDooKu. After seeing a cross section of the internal workings of a PVB, I see there is no reason I can't install it indoors. I see that if you were to loose main water supply pressure to the PVB (extremely unlikely), AND you have a situation where backflow pressure was possible (such as downstream plumbing was above the PVB discharge), then water could backflow through the drain vent. But, in my situation where the PVB is mounted more than 12" above grade AND THE HIGHEST DOWNSTREAM DISCHARGE POINT, backflow is all but impossible (water doesn't flow up hill). Perhaps aquamatic should educate himself if he believes that (codes) "only allow PVB's on residential due to the fact that they flush out of the top and one is able to notice that it did and you know that it is working correctly". The only way a PVB could flush out of the top in my situation is if it were to mechanically fail. Thanks again HooKooDooKu

Thursday, April 22nd 2004, 6:10pm

by HooKooDooKu

There is nothing wrong with installing a PVB indoors (from a safety stand point). It's just that if something does occur that attempts to "push" the water backwards, the PVB keeps you safe by spilling water out the top of it rather than letting it flow backwards into the plumbing that feeds potable water to the house (so you could end up with a wet basement, or where ever you install the PVB).

But for the PVB to operate correctly, the water line must be under constant pressure (therefore the PVB is installed upstream of any irrigation valves) and it can not be submerged (therefore the code specification that it be 12" above grade.

Thursday, April 22nd 2004, 10:52am

by aquamatic

A PVB (Pressure Vacume Breaker)purpose is when you do have back pressure situation, the device will automatically dump the reverse flow from your sprinkler system out of the top and onto the ground. The whole mechanics of it only work with your main under pressure.

Most counties atleast here in the east coast only allow PVB's on residential due to the fact that they flush out of the top and one is able to notice that it did and you know that it is working correctly.

I'm not sure if your getting into the business of irrigation- if you are you need to educate yourself on backflow prevention (Cross Connection)

If these devices are not installed and working properly- You can easily kill people with contaminated drinking water.

If you are using a well water source that is only for irrigation, no need for these devices.

If anyone wants a great resource on Backflow prevention, send me your email and I'll send you a pdf file

pgsystems@cox.net